This story was initially revealed by Healthbeat. Join their public well being newsletters at healthbeat.org/newsletters.
As principal of Dunaire Elementary Faculty, Sean Deas has seen firsthand the struggles confronted by youngsters residing in extended-stay lodges. About 10% of scholars at his faculty, simply east of Atlanta, reside in a single.
The kids, Deas stated, typically have been uncovered to violence on lodge properties, exhibit aggression or nervousness from residing in a crowded single room, and face meals insecurity as a result of some lodge rooms don’t have kitchens.
“Social trauma is the largest problem” when college students first arrive, Deas stated. “We hear so much about sleep issues.” To satisfy college students’ wants, Deas developed a schoolwide program that includes counselors, a meals pantry, and particular protocols for dealing with those that could go to sleep in school.
“Past the educating, there’s a social half,” he stated. “We now have to seek out methods to help the households as effectively.”
Prolonged-stay lodges are sometimes a final resort for low-income households looking for housing. Nationally, greater than 100,000 college students lived in extended-stay lodges in 2022, in keeping with the Division of Schooling, although officers say that’s probably an undercount. Youngsters residing in lodges are thought of homeless below federal legislation, and in some Atlanta-area counties about 40% of homeless college students reside in this sort of housing, in keeping with native officers.
And with rising rents and evictions, and decreased entry to federal public housing, the usage of extended-stay lodges as a long-term choice is changing into extra frequent. Like different types of homelessness, lodge residing can result in — or exacerbate — bodily and psychological well being issues for youngsters, say advocates for households and researchers who examine homelessness.
Within the Atlanta space, inspections of extended-stay lodges have revealed air flow points, insect infestations, mould, and different well being threats. Youngsters residing there can also expertise or witness crime and gun violence. The rising use of extended-stay lodges is a warning signal, observers stated, a mirrored image of the shortage of ample inexpensive housing coverage in america.
And the disaster is having “lifelong penalties,” stated Sarah Saadian of the Nationwide Low Revenue Housing Coalition. “The one method that we will actually handle that scarcity is that if there are important federal sources at scale. Construct extra housing and bridge the hole between rents and wages.”
Usually, evictions drive households into lodges — and might maintain them trapped there. Many landlords refuse to hire to folks with evictions of their credit score historical past, even when the tenant isn’t accountable for the displacement, stated Pleasure Monroe, founder and CEO of the Single Mum or dad Alliance & Useful resource Middle, a nonprofit group in metro Atlanta that has helped lots of of households transfer from lodges to residences or rental houses.
Black ladies and different ladies of coloration, typically with children, are evicted at a lot greater charges and usually tend to discover themselves residing in extended-stay lodges, advocates say.
Some residents are additionally households fleeing home violence, they are saying.
Inns provide quick aid, however host different issues
Inns typically don’t require safety deposits, software charges, or background checks, thus offering quick aid for households in search of shelter. Whereas there are higher-end choices, the typical charge for an economy-class extended-stay room was $56.68 an evening throughout the first three months of 2024, in keeping with the Highland Group, a analysis agency that focuses on the lodge sector — which works out to greater than $1,700 a month.
And whereas the rooms provide respite from different types of homelessness — like sleeping in a automotive or in a tent — a lodge “is not any place to boost youngsters,” stated Michael Bryant, CEO of New Life Neighborhood Alliance, which helps households in South Dekalb, part of metro Atlanta, transfer from lodges to houses.
Youngsters residing in lodges are sometimes behind on vaccinations, they usually could find yourself within the emergency room due to delays in care, stated Gary Kirkilas, a pediatrician in Phoenix who helps youngsters, teenagers, and households who’re homeless or vulnerable to homelessness. About 75% of kids with unstable housing whom he sees have no less than one developmental delay, and others expertise important emotional and behavioral points.
Tanazia Scott, who has bounced between two extended-stay lodges for a number of months, stated her three youngsters “really feel depressed and upset” over lodge life.
An eviction despatched Kassandra Norman, 58, and her two daughters right into a months-long journey of staying in Atlanta-area lodges. For 3 months, they slept in a automotive exterior a comfort retailer. “It’s onerous to do homework in a automotive and within the lodge,” stated 19-year-old Kazuri Taylor, Norman’s youthful daughter.
Some lodges prohibit children from enjoying exterior of their parking tons, resulting in further stress, advocates say. That was the rationale Yvonne Thomas, 45, and her household had been evicted from an extended-stay lodge in DeKalb County, she stated: “They put us out for nothing.”
And there are different issues. Greater than a dozen college students at Dunaire Elementary reside on an extended-stay property referred to as Haven Lodge. In August, DeKalb County’s code enforcement division stated the lodge had “not maintained minimal life security requirements.” Roaches and spiders reside in rooms and breezeways, in keeping with state well being inspection experiences. Residents say they’ve been charged $1 for a roll of bathroom paper.
The lodge’s proprietor and supervisor couldn’t be reached for remark after a number of makes an attempt.
“Nobody is speaking about these households,” stated Sue Sullivan, a neighborhood advocate and a volunteer with the Motel to Residence coalition in Atlanta, who brings toys, bookbags, meals, and toiletries on her lodge visits.
A February public well being inspection at one other DeKalb County lodge discovered a number of rooms with poor air flow, insect infestation, and mould, amongst different potential well being threats. In Might, two folks had been fatally shot there.
Youngsters who witness violence can develop nervousness, melancholy, and different problems, stated Charles Moore, director of the City Well being Initiative at Emory College Faculty of Medication. “They’ll really feel emotional aftershocks,” stated Moore, who has visited Atlanta-area lodges.
Advocates are discovering inventive options
Closing such lodges, nonetheless, can harm households, given the scarcity of inexpensive housing, the absence of nationwide federal renter protections, and a dearth of locations to go, stated Terri Lewinson, an affiliate professor on the Dartmouth Institute for Well being Coverage and Medical Observe. Prolonged-stay lodges do “provide a low-barrier choice for households who don’t have any different choices,” she stated.
To alleviate the housing drawback, county officers and nonprofit organizations across the nation have been creatively filling the hole. Within the Seattle space, for instance, King County officers bought lodges and transformed them into inexpensive housing, stated Mark Skinner of the Highland Group.
In metro Atlanta, SPARC and the native United Approach’s Motel to Residence provide funding to assist folks transition into an house.
In DeKalb County, the place Dunaire Elementary Faculty is positioned, greater than a 3rd of the 1,300 homeless college students reside in lodges, in keeping with Commissioner Ted Terry.
“I hope we will rescue the youngsters,” he stated. “It’s not a secure setting for them.”
Advocates who search to assist folks residing in lodges suggest the development of extra inexpensive housing and stronger protections for renters towards eviction. The federal authorities has didn’t put money into repairs wanted to keep up present public housing models, and 25-year-old laws successfully prohibits the development of recent public housing.
It’s additionally “extraordinarily quick, straightforward, and low-cost” to evict tenants in Georgia, stated Taylor Shelton, an affiliate professor of geosciences at Georgia State College, whose analysis focuses on social inequalities and concrete areas. “The enjoying discipline is tilted closely towards landlords.”
Underneath such circumstances, the cycle of poverty is troublesome to interrupt, stated Jamie Rush, a senior employees lawyer on the Southern Poverty Legislation Middle. “Most dad and mom would need their children in a secure, secure house,” Rush stated. “You’ll be able to’t price range your method out of poverty.”
Andy Miller and Renuka Rayasam are reporters with KFF Well being Information, Healthbeat’s nationwide reporting associate.
