Join Chalkbeat New York’s free day by day e-newsletter to maintain up with NYC’s public colleges.
New York Metropolis’s lecturers union has been a key supporter of the formidable effort to overtake the literacy curriculum in elementary faculty, nevertheless it’s been a really totally different story in terms of a giant math curriculum push.
Faculties Chancellor David Banks is mandating virtually each metropolis highschool undertake the similar curriculum for Algebra I – a transfer that United Federation of Lecturers president Michael Mulgrew in current weeks has been publicly criticizing in stark phrases.
“We’ve got a large number on our fingers,” Mulgrew advised Chalkbeat this week. “I’ve been to a variety of excessive colleges, and in each faculty, they’re telling us the identical precise factor: that ultimately, the scholars are going to be harmed.”
Mulgrew’s opposition is a dramatic flip from the union’s literacy assist, and comes at an important second for the nascent math curriculum overhaul. After rolling out Illustrative Math — a curriculum that emphasizes open-ended actions and pupil dialogue — to roughly 260 excessive colleges final yr, officers expanded it citywide this yr, whereas additionally mandating roughly 100 center colleges to make use of one in every of three pre-approved math curriculums.
The union chief’s pushback might spell bother for the Schooling Division, particularly at a time of transition. The division is already navigating the turmoil of an abrupt management change and chaos in metropolis corridor following Mayor Eric Adams’ indictment.
One looming query is how the curriculum shift will influence college students’ scores on the Algebra I Regents examination, a state-mandated take a look at on the finish of the course that college students should move to maneuver on to higher-level math programs and graduate.
Whereas officers have but to share citywide outcomes for final yr’s Algebra I Regents, some early outcomes are sparking concern.
Josephine Van Ess, superintendent of Queens South Excessive Faculties, whose district participated in final yr’s Illustrative Math pilot, advised mother or father leaders Algebra I Regents move charges in her district fell from 59% in 2023 to 45% final yr, the New York Publish first reported. Van Ess attributed the drop partly to the brand new curriculum and referenced “a decline throughout town” in Algebra I Regents scores.
The take a look at additionally modified final yr, making it troublesome to do an apples-to-apples comparability with 2023, however educators mentioned the modifications weren’t intensive.
Mulgrew mentioned union officers weren’t concerned in planning the maths curriculum modifications and have been elevating issues for the previous yr over the curriculum’s lack of remediation for college kids far behind grade stage, unrealistic expectations about how rapidly lecturers ought to transfer by way of classes, and misalignment with the Algebra I Regents examination.
Increasing it this yr was “doubling down on a nasty guess,” Mulgrew mentioned.
Schooling officers are holding agency. Banks has argued that math outcomes had been so underwhelming throughout town, and riddled with so many inequities, that he needed to strive one thing new and impressive. Simply 48% of Black and Latino metropolis college students who took the Algebra I Regents in 2023 handed, in comparison with 74% of white and 83% of Asian-American college students, in response to state information.
Huge new curriculum efforts typically result in early “implementation dips,” officers have argued.
“We’re taking part in the lengthy sport right here,” Banks mentioned at a September press convention.
And lots of educators assist the philosophy behind the brand new curriculum, which pushes college students to find math ideas on their very own reasonably than counting on lecturers to elucidate guidelines that college students then memorize and apply. Schooling Division officers emphasised that lecturers new to the curriculum are receiving intensive skilled improvement.
Deputy Chancellor Danika Rux, who’s overseeing the curriculum overhaul, mentioned addressing the union’s issues is a “precedence for us.” She mentioned officers are assembly with the union to listen to their issues and rapidly handle them. ”We’re dedicated to creating this work,” she mentioned.
Debates flare over content material, rollout of latest curriculum
From the outset, the sweeping curriculum modifications have drawn clashing responses from educators.
A number of the disputes replicate a long-simmering pressure in math training between giving college students room to discover and uncover concepts on their very own, and providing direct instruction with apply and repetition.
“You arising with what ‘congruent’ means, that can persist with you numerous longer than if anyone’s telling you the definition of ‘congruent,’” Rux advised reporters who participated Thursday in a pattern Illustrative Math lesson at Fannie Lou Hamer Center Faculty within the Bronx.
However some educators mentioned it’s merely not lifelike to anticipate college students to be taught math expertise with out a lot of built-in time for drilling and apply.
“The entire discovery is one factor, however not having the ability to truly make it ‘sticky’ is absolutely one thing that I struggled with,” mentioned one Brooklyn math trainer who participated in final yr’s Illustrative Math pilot and spoke on the situation of anonymity for concern of retaliation. “The extra [students] apply, the extra they maintain. However there was little or no apply truly supplied within the [Illustrative Math] curriculum.”
The Brooklyn trainer mentioned he appreciates features of the brand new curriculum, and has used actions from it for years, however took difficulty with town’s rollout of the mandate.
“Folks had been simply getting insane burnout,” he mentioned. “All these things was coming down from the highest. All of it, we had been being advised you need to do it by this date.”
His expertise educating Illustrative Math final yr was so draining that he determined to cease educating math this yr, he mentioned.
Lecturers specific issues over quick tempo of curriculum
For Mulgrew, the stress to maintain shifting by way of the curriculum prevents lecturers from stopping and shoring up lagging foundational expertise for struggling college students when it’s wanted.
“Figuring out that almost all of [their] college students aren’t getting this, [teachers] can’t again off to do any form of remediation to attempt to assist them, as a result of [they] have to remain on this pacing calendar,” he mentioned. “That is insane.”
However some educators say persevering with to supply difficult actions even whereas some college students want additional assist is a part of the purpose.
“The results of focusing all your consideration on what college students don’t know and remediating one thing from earlier grades is a scarcity of fairness within the grade-level content material that college students are allowed to be taught,” mentioned Emma Comstock Reid, a Fannie Lou Hamer algebra trainer.
Comstock Reid, who has been utilizing Illustrative Math for years, added that the curriculum does embrace “adaptation packs” to assist assist youngsters behind grade stage. Officers added that the curriculum’s open-ended actions enable college students at totally different grade ranges to contribute.
Educators have additionally raised issues that the curriculum doesn’t align nicely with the year-end Regents examination. And whereas the long-term destiny of the Regents exams is murky, they play a important position now in college students’ skill to graduate and transfer on to higher-level math programs.
Schooling Division officers urged endurance with the take a look at scores.
“There’s something to be realized” from the Queens district that noticed a giant drop in Algebra I Regents scores this yr, together with the necessity for extra skilled improvement for lecturers, mentioned Miatheresa Pate, town’s interim chief of lecturers and instruction. “All information is nice information.”
Michael Elsen-Rooney is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, protecting NYC public colleges. Contact Michael at melsen-rooney@chalkbeat.org.
